https://ces.uc.pt/summerwinterschools/?lang=2&id=3553

CES Summer School

Environmental Values and Public Policies

July 12 to 15, 2011

Lousã

Home

 2nd CES “Critical Economics” Summer School

Environmental Values and Public Policies

Lousã (Portugal), 12th-15th of July 2011

 

The CES “Critical Economics Summer School”, launched in 2009, brings together in annual meetings economists and other social scientists to discuss topics of shared interest. This series of summer schools aims at promoting a forum for critical research on the economy and in economics. The school is primarily intended for PhD students and post-doctoral researchers as well as young scholars.

This second edition of the Summer School is devoted to analyze how the growing relevance of environment, recognized as a “good” and as a “problem” of our societies, challenges public policy instruments and procedures that allow government policy on environmental issues to be made material and operational. These instruments and procedures are significantly relying on economic theories and expertise. The creation of environmental markets is one clear example of the importance of economic theory in shaping societal answers to the environmental crisis. The problem with economics applied to the environment is that economics has a specific and limited definition of the value of the environment. Through exploring the dimension of environmental value pluralism with insights coming from sociology and philosophy, we want to discuss the limits of existing economic instruments and procedures and explore alternative pathways (included conflict and participation) allowing for the taking into account of the various ways in which environments matter to people and to their communities.      

The speakers will be invited to discuss three main topics:

1) Environmental values and valuation

We are interested in exploring economic valuation as one of the possible ways to value the environment. Philosophical and sociological  approaches to the issue of the plurality of forms of valuing environment are here discussed. We are interested as well in the issue of how the plurality of forms of valuing environment can be composed in public decision processes, especially through deliberation.

2) Environmental markets

We are interested in exploring the socio-technical construction of environmental markets, and the instruments relying on environmental markets (like CBA), entering into the details of the operations of commensuration that are needed in order to create them and their limits in terms of neglecting value pluralism.

3) Public decision and the environment: participation and conflict

We are interested in discussing the complexity of public decision processes concerning environmental issues and the place for participation and conflict as active contributions to the reshaping of public policies.

 

Guest lecturers include John O’Neill from the University of Manchester (Manchester, UK), Laurent Thévenot from the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (Paris, France) and Clive Spash from the Vienna University of Economics and Business (Vienna, Austria). CES Lecturers include José Maria Castro Caldas, João Rodrigues, Laura Centemeri, Stefania Barca.

 

Course language wil be English.

Interested PhD students, post-docs and early stage researchers are encouraged to apply by submitting a curriculum vitae and a two-page abstract of the proposed paper, together with the author’s contact details (Name, affiliation, email address) to criticaleconomics2011@ces.uc.pt.

 

Deadline for submissions is April 22nd 2011.

Acceptance will be communicated by email by May 1st 2011.

Final papers are due by July 7th 2011. 

Program

Program

 

Monday, 11th of July

19.00: Transport of participants from Coimbra to Lousã. Meeting point in Coimbra at CES, Largo D.Dinis.

 

Tuesday, 12th of July - Environmental values and valuation

Morning:

9.30-10.15: Opening session: presentation of participants

10.30-13.00: Laurent Thévenot (INSEE-EHESS)

 

Afternoon:

14.30-16.00: Laura Centemeri (CES)

16.00-16.30: Coffee Break

16.30-18.30: parallel sessions of students groups 

 

Wednesday, 13th of July - Public decision and the environment 

Morning:

9.30-11.00: John O’Neill (Manchester University)

11.00-11.30: Coffee Break

11.30-12.30: John O’Neill (Manchester University)

 

Afternoon:

14.30-16.00: José Maria Castro Caldas (CES)

18.00-19.30 Visit to the city of Lousa

 

Thursday, 14th of July - Environmental Markets

Morning:

9.30-11.00: João Rodrigues and Ricardo Coelho (CES)

11.00-11.30: Coffee Break

11.30-12.30 Clive Spash (WU Vienna University of Economics and Business)

 

Afternoon:

14.30-16.30: Clive Spash (WU Vienna University of Economics and Business)

16.30-17.00: Coffee Break 

17.00-18.30: parallel sessions of students groups

 

Friday, 15th of July

Morning:

9.00-12.30 Visit to Poços da Neve, Candal, Castelo.

 

Afternoon:

14.00- 15.00: Closing session

16.00: Transport of participants from Lousã to Coimbra b Station.

 

Venue

Venue

 

The Summer School will be held at the Meliá Palácio da Lousã. Formerly Palace of Viscondessa do Espinhal, it is classified as Historical Heritage. It is located in Lousã's historical city center, with stunning views of Lousã Mountain.

Guide

Guide

 

Transport to Coimbra
If you arrive at Lisboa or Porto by plain, train or bus, you can take the train or the bus to Coimbra.
If you take the train, you can choose between the Intercidades or the Alfa. The latter is a bit faster but also more expensive. In the rail company’s website (www.cp.pt) you can search for schedules and prices. The train stations are Gare do Oriente in Lisboa and Campanhã in Porto (instructions below).
The train leaves you at Coimbra-B station. From there you can take another train to Coimbra station, which usually departs about 15-20 minutes later, using the same ticket, and you will be at the center of the city. Alternatively, you can take the bus (insctructions below).
You may prefer to travel by bus with Rede Expresso (http://www.rede-expressos.pt/default.aspx). From Lisboa, you just have to go to Gare do Oriente and you can buy the ticket on the first floor above the bus stop. From Porto, you will have to go to Batalha, which can be a tad more confusing so see the map below.

From Lisboa-Airport to Lisboa-Gare do Oriente
When you leave the Airport you can take a taxi to Gare do Oriente, from where you can take the train or bus to Coimbra. The journey shouldn’t take more than 10 minutes.
Alternatively, you can take the bus. If you carry large luggage you will be directed to the aeroshuttle (bus 96, timetables http://www.carris.pt/en/bus/96/ascendente/ and http://www.carris.pt/en/bus/96/descendente/). You can buy the ticket on the bus for 3.5€.
If you don’t carry large luggage (i.e., if you only have a backpack or a bag) you can take the 705, which is a regular line (timetable: http://www.carris.pt/en/bus/705/descendente/ and http://www.carris.pt/en/bus/705/ascendente/).  You can buy the ticket on the bus for 1.5€ or you can buy a rechargeable card with two trips for 2.3€ (the card costs 0.5€) inside the Airport, in “Clube TAP” (ask a security guard for directions). If you have a card, you will have to validate the journey inside the bus each trip, using the machine available inside.
Also note that if you want to visit Lisboa you can take the aerobus to the city center. To go to the Gare do Oriente, you just have to take the subway and leave in the end of the red line.

From Porto-Airport to Porto-Campanhã (train)
The easiest and cheapest way to make this journey is to take the metro. In front of the Airport you will find a metro station. Just follow the signs through the tunnel that goes underneath the road and you’ll be there. The trip is direct.
To buy a ticket you must go to one of the machines available and buy a “Andante” card with two Z4 journeys (3€ + 0.5€ for the card). You have to validate the ticket in the validation points before each journey. If you want to visit Porto you can leave in Trindade and you will be next to the city center.

From Porto-Airport to Porto-Batalha (bus)
To go to the city center, just follow the instructions above for the metro. You will want to leave in São Bento, so you have to leave the metro in Trindade, go down the stairs, validate your ticket again and take the yellow line in the direction of D. João II. When you leave in São Bento you will have to walk a bit (600m). The bus station is at Rua Alexandre Herculano, 366.
You can find a map here: http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&source=s_d&saddr=Sao+Bento,+Porto,+Portugal&daddr=Rua+de+Alexandre+Herculano,+366,+Porto,+Portugal&hl=pt-PT&geocode=FWrScwIdAZx8_ynbNxT342QkDTFqn59PWnR1Wg%3BFXTQcwIdY698_ykRYfUI5mQkDTE4w6fnrpFwmw&mra=ls&dirflg=w&sll=41.144938,-8.610815&sspn=0.0069,0.019763&ie=UTF8&ll=41.144503,-8.608153&spn=0.00345,0.009881&t=h&z=17.

 

Transport to Lousã
Lousã is located near Coimbra. We will have a bus departing from the University on the 11th July at 19h. Below you will find instructions on how to get there.

From Coimbra-B or the bus station to the University
When you leave the station, you can take either a taxi or a bus. If you choose the bus, you have to take the nr. 5 (timetable here http://www.smtuc.pt/geral/index_horarios.php) and leave in the 4th or 5th stop, next to the Monumental Stairs. These are huge stairs that lead to the University, so you can’t miss them. After climbing the stairs, you will meet the statue of D. Dinis, the founder of the University and our bus will be right there.
There’s also a direct bus, the 1A, but you have to check the link above for the timetable because the frequency is very low. If you’re lucky enough that you have one when you get to the station, this is the best option.

From Coimbra-A to the University
From Coimbra-B you can take the regional train that will take you to Coimbra-A (named just Coimbra in the train billboards) using the same ticket that got you there. Leaving Coimbra-A you can take the bus or walk up. If you take the bus, you just have to leave the station through the side stairs, instead of using the front door and you can take either the bus 4 or 103.
If you’re feeling energetic and want to know the inside of this hilly small town you can walk up (about 1km). Here you can see the shortest way: http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&source=s_d&saddr=Av.+Em%C3%ADdio+Navarro&daddr=Pra%C3%A7a+Dinis&hl=pt-PT&geocode=FQeJZQIdNFd__w%3BFVOHZQId2Xp__w&mra=dme&mrsp=1&sz=17&dirflg=w&sll=40.208393,-8.426546&sspn=0.003499,0.009881&ie=UTF8&ll=40.208074,-8.428048&spn=0.003499,0.009881&t=h&z=17. You can just make your own route, though, wandering around the streets. Just turn left after leaving the station and you will be in the center. As the University is on the top of the hill, you can never get lost in Coimbra – just look up, follow the tower with the clock and keep climbing.

 

Links with tourist information:
Coimbra: http://www.turismodecoimbra.pt/index.php?lang=en
Porto: http://www.visitporto.travel/Visitar/Paginas/default.aspx
Lisboa: http://www.visitlisboa.com/Home_UK.aspx?lang=en-GB

 pdf version

Participants

Participants

 

Abstracts (pdf)

Name Affiliation Title of the abstract Working Group Email contact
Alessandro Bonifazi Technical University of Bari Evaluation and environmental democratization of urban governance Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies  a.bonifazi@poliba.it
Anne Dickson University of Sidney Business School Corporate carbon reporting: do leading practices imply leading emissions reductions? Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices a.dickson@econ.usyd.edu.au
António Patrão CES-Universidade de Coimbra Collaborative practices: exploring new ways of preventing and coping with forest fires Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies  antoniopatrao@gmail.com
Carlos Ferreira University of Manchester Markets for biodiversity conservation: conflicting ideas of no net loss Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies carlos.ferreira@postgrad.mbs.ac.uk
Daniela Pantani Universidade de Coimbra, Faculdade de Economia Whose responsibility is it? The strategy of corporate social responsibility in the context of Brazilian environmental policies Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices daniela.pantani@gmail.com
David Sumares Universidade de Aveiro – Departamento de Ambiente e Ordenamento Natura 2000 and the valuation of Nature within Strategic Environmental Assessment — The case of the “Ria de Aveiro Coastline Polis” Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies david.sumares@ua.pt
Deborah Werner Universidade Estadual de Campinas Environmental and social participation in decision making about the hydroelectric dams in the Amazon region: the case of the Madeira Complex Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies deborah_werner@hotmail.com
Irene Tomasoni Catholic University, Brescia Green technologies: resistance and social (non) acceptance Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices ire.tomasoni@gmail.com
Lidiane Carvalho CES-Universidade de Coimbra The public management of social and environmental funds: The case of the National Fund for the Environment in Brazil1 Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies lidicarvalho@hotmail.com
Louison Cahen-Fourot University of Auvergne – Clermont-Ferrand The institutional analysis of payments for environmental services governance mechanisms through transaction costs: what do we learn on the nature of PES and on their conditions of emergence? Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies louison.cahenfourot@gmail.com
Lucia Dal Negro Catholic University, Milan Inclusive business in emerging countries: the role of formal and informal authorities in managing environmental concerns Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices  lucia.dalnegro@unicatt.it
Makbule Nisa Mencet Akdeniz University Vocational School Greenhouse production system choices: is modern technology better for environment? Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices nmencet@akdeniz.edu.tr
Maria Proestou Humboldt University Berlin, Faculty of Agriculture and Horticulture How do we delibrate over our environment? The case of wind energy implementation on the island of Amorgos Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies melinpr@hotmail.com
Osiel González Dávila University of London, School of Oriental and African Studies Arsenic and fluoride groundwater contamination in Zacatecas, Mexico Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies osielgonzalezdavila@hotmail.com
Ossi Ollinaho Aalto University, Institute of Strategy Environment – Somebody else's problem Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies ossi.ollinaho@gmail.com
Rita Sao Marcos Universidade dos Açores Integrated risk governance of a termite urban pest, challenges in risk communication: mediating conflicts in a public decision process Group 3 – Values, valuation and public policies ritasaomarcos@gmail.com
Romain Debref Université Reims Champagne-Ardenne Towards biomimicry technologies - a paradox for a sustainable transition ? An evolutionary analysis of ecodesign for green chemistry Group 1 – Technology and corporate practices romain.debref@univ-reims.fr
Tone Smith Spash WU Vienna University of Economics and Business The role of numbers in environmental decision processes Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies tonesmi@yahoo.no
Wiepke Wissema Dublin University Sustainable public decision-making, ethics and communication Group 2 – Public decision, markets and deliberation: environmental values and controversies wwissema@gmail.com

 

Fee

 Fee

 

Registration fee: 50 € for students and 150 € for non-students

Accommodation costs + meals from the night of the 11th of July to the afternoon of the 15th of July: 250 €

 

The organization may subsidize a small number of students, especially students coming from outside Europe. The decision will be based on the interest of the proposed paper and subject to proof of student status.

 

Important dates

Important dates

 

Deadline for submissions is April 22nd 2011.

Interested graduate students and post-docs are encouraged to apply by submitting a curriculum vitae and a two-page abstract of the proposed paper, together with the author’s contact details (Name, affiliation, email address) to criticaleconomics2011@ces.uc.pt.

Acceptance will be communicated by email by May 1st 2011.

Deadline for registrations is June 15 th.

Final papers are due by July 7th 2011.

July 12th-15th : Summer School

Reading List

Reading List

 

Laurent Thévenot

Thévenot, L. (forthcoming). BOUNDED JUSTIFIABILITY. Making commonality on the basis of binding engagements. In Dumouchel Paul and Gotoh Reiko (eds.) Bounds and Boundaries: New Perspectives on Justice and Culture, Cambridge, Ma., Cambridge University Press.

 
Thévenot L., 2011, Conventions for Measuring and questioning Policies. The case of 50 years of policy evaluations through a statistical survey. Working paper INSEE.

 

John O’Neill

O'Neill, J., Holland, A., Light, A., 2008. Environmental Values. London: Routledge. Ch. 1 “Values and the environment”.


O'Neill, J., Holland, A., Light, A., 2008. Environmental Values. London: Routledge. Ch. 2 “Human well-being and the natural world”


O'Neill, J., Holland, A., Light, A., 2008. Environmental Values. London: Routledge. Ch. 5 “Value pluralism, value commensurability and environmental choice”.  

 

Clive Spash

O'Neill, J., Spash, C.L., 2000. “Conceptions of value in environmental decision-making”. Environmental Values 9, 521-536.


Spash, C.L., 2008. “Deliberative monetary valuation and the evidence for a new value theory”. Land Economics 84, 469-488.


Spash, C.L., 2010. “The brave new world of carbon trading”. New Polit. Econ. 15, 169-195.

 

Joao Rodrigues and Ricardo Coelho

Lohmann, L., 2010. “Uncertainty Markets and Carbon Markets: Variations on Polanyian Themes”. New Political Economy, 15(2), 225–254.


MacKenzie, D., 2009. “Making things the same: Gases, emission rights and the politics of carbon markets.” Accounting, Organizations and Society, 34 (3-4), 440-455.

 

José Maria Castro Caldas

Martinez-Alier, J., Munda, G., O'Neill, J., 1998. “Weak comparability of values as a foundation for ecological economics”. Ecological Economics, 26(3), 277-286.

 

Laura Centemeri

Thévenot, L., Moody, M., Lafaye, C., 2000. “Forms of Valuing Nature: Arguments and Modes of Justification in French and American Environmental Disputes”, in Lamont Michèle and Thévenot Laurent (eds.), Rethinking Comparative Cultural Sociology: Repertoires of Evaluation in France and the United States, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 229-272.

 
Thévenot, L., Moody, M., 2000. “Comparing Models of Strategy, Interests, and the Public Good in French and American Environmental Disputes”, in Lamont Michèle and Thévenot Laurent (eds.), Rethinking comparative cultural sociology: Repertoires of Evaluation in France and the United States, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 273-306.

 

Stefania Barca

Martinez-Alier, J., 2009. “Social Metabolism, Ecological Distribution Conflicts, and Languages of Valuation.” Capitalism Nature Socialism, 20(1), 58 – 87.

 
Armiero, M., 2008. “Seeing Like a Protester: Nature, Power, and Environmental Struggles.” Left History, 13(1), 59-76.

 

Organizing Committee
Support

 

 

Contact

Contact

 

For any questions please contact us at criticaleconomics2011@ces.uc.pt

Home Program Venue Guide Participants Fee Important dates Reading List Organizing Committee Support Contact Photos